Employer Insights
The finance talent is out there. Why is finding the right hire still so difficult?
Why do Singapore employers struggle to fill finance roles despite having experienced candidates in the market? Futureleap explores evolving job requirements, transferable skills and a more thoughtful approach to hiring.
5 min read

A familiar hiring challenge
A Finance Manager vacancy opens. The job description is prepared, the position is advertised, and applications begin arriving.
Some candidates have strong accounting backgrounds. Others bring regional reporting experience, financial planning and analysis (FP&A), or commercial finance exposure.
Yet after reviewing the applications, the hiring manager may still feel that something is missing.
The candidates are qualified, but not quite right.
This is a familiar challenge in finance recruitment. While candidate availability matters, the difficulty of filling a role does not always mean there is an absolute shortage of finance professionals.
Sometimes, the challenge lies in how the role itself has evolved.
Finance roles are no longer as clearly defined
Traditionally, finance functions were often organised around relatively distinct responsibilities.
Financial accounting focused on reporting, compliance and controls. FP&A concentrated on budgeting, forecasting and performance analysis. Treasury managed liquidity and financial risk, while commercial finance supported business decisions.
These distinctions still exist, but the boundaries have become less rigid.
A Financial Controller may now be expected to contribute to strategic planning, lead systems improvements and provide commercial insights.
A Finance Manager may be responsible not only for month-end reporting and statutory compliance, but also for business partnering, process automation and regional coordination.
Even FP&A positions can vary considerably. One employer may prioritise forecasting and management reporting, while another expects pricing analysis, operational performance management and close engagement with business leaders.
The job titles may look familiar, but the expectations behind them can be quite different.
This creates a recruitment challenge: employers may be searching for combinations of experience that are not commonly found in one individual.
When the ideal candidate becomes difficult to find
Consider a Finance Manager position requiring:
Strong financial reporting and technical accounting knowledge
Regional exposure across multiple markets
Commercial finance and business partnering capabilities
Experience with ERP implementation or process transformation
Prior experience in the employer's specific industry
The ability to manage a team and engage senior stakeholders
Individually, these requirements are reasonable.
Collectively, however, they can narrow the available talent pool considerably, particularly when salary expectations, seniority and career motivations must also align.
This does not mean employers should compromise on important requirements.
Rather, it raises a useful question: Which capabilities are essential from day one, and which could a capable professional develop after joining?
The distinction can make a meaningful difference to a search.
For example, an experienced Financial Controller from a different industry may possess the technical depth, leadership ability and systems exposure required for a role, even without direct sector experience.
Similarly, a strong Senior Finance Manager may be ready to step into a broader regional position despite not having held the exact job title previously.
Assessing potential alongside experience can widen the field without necessarily lowering standards.
The importance of understanding what the business actually needs
An effective finance hire begins with clarity about the business problem the appointment is intended to solve.
Is the organisation strengthening financial controls following rapid expansion?
Does it need more reliable forecasting and management information?
Is the finance team undergoing a systems transformation?
Or does the business require a stronger commercial partner to support operational decisions?
These situations may all lead to a vacancy carrying the title Finance Manager or Financial Controller, but the most suitable candidate profile could differ substantially.
A business facing reporting and compliance challenges may need a technically strong finance leader who can establish robust processes.
An organisation seeking to improve profitability may benefit more from someone with commercial analysis and stakeholder-management experience.
Understanding these priorities helps employers distinguish between essential capabilities and desirable experience.
It also enables candidates to be evaluated against the outcomes they are expected to deliver, rather than solely against a list of previous responsibilities.
Why looking beyond active applicants matters
Another consideration is where employers search for talent.
Job advertisements remain an important recruitment channel, particularly for professionals actively exploring opportunities.
However, not every suitable finance professional is actively applying for jobs.
Some may be performing well in their current organisations and would consider a move only if the opportunity offers meaningful career progression, broader responsibilities or an attractive business challenge.
Others may not immediately recognise themselves in a job description, especially when the requirements appear unusually extensive.
This is where a broader approach to talent identification becomes useful.
Rather than relying exclusively on applications, employers can benefit from understanding the wider market, including professionals whose experience may be transferable and those who are open to the right opportunity without actively searching.
The objective is not simply to generate more candidates.
It is to identify a more relevant range of candidates and understand what each could bring to the role.
A more thoughtful approach to finance hiring
As finance functions continue to evolve, successful hiring increasingly requires a balance between technical competence, business understanding and future potential.
For employers, several questions are worth considering before beginning a search:
What must this person deliver in the first 12 months?
Which skills are genuinely non-negotiable?
Could relevant experience from another industry or adjacent finance function translate successfully?
Are the role's expectations aligned with its seniority and remuneration?
Are we evaluating candidates for the work they will actually perform, or primarily for how closely their CV matches the job description?
These questions do not eliminate the challenges of recruitment.
They can, however, help employers approach the market with greater clarity and make more informed hiring decisions.
Finding the right fit, not simply the closest match
Singapore has a substantial community of experienced accounting and finance professionals, with capabilities developed across industries, business models and regional markets.
That does not mean every vacancy will be easy to fill. Specialist expertise, leadership experience, compensation expectations and individual career preferences can all affect the available pool.
But a difficult search should not automatically be interpreted as evidence that suitable talent does not exist.
Sometimes, the opportunity lies in reassessing how the role is defined, where candidates are identified and how their capabilities are evaluated.
For employers, the goal should not necessarily be to find someone who has already done everything listed in the job description.
It is to identify the professional best equipped to deliver what the business needs next.
Futureleap specialises in Accounting & Finance recruitment in Singapore, combining market insight, targeted talent identification and engagement with experienced finance professionals. Our approach focuses on understanding the requirements behind each appointment and helping employers make informed hiring decisions.
Updated 11 November 2026